I’ve been cultivating an affinity to Caitlin Flanagan for some time now. But this takes the cake:
Imagine that as a young and desperately poor Mexican man, you had made the dangerous and illegal journey to California to work in the fields with other migrants. There, you performed stoop labor, picking lettuce and bell peppers and table grapes; what made such an existence bearable was the dream of a better life. You met a woman and had a child with her, and because that child was born in the U.S., he was made a citizen of this great country. He will lead a life entirely different from yours; he will be educated. Now that child is about to begin middle school in the American city whose name is synonymous with higher learning, as it is the home of one of the greatest universities in the world: Berkeley. On the first day of sixth grade, the boy walks though the imposing double doors of his new school, stows his backpack, and then heads out to the field, where he stoops under a hot sun and begins to pick lettuce.
Not for the first time have the fads of the upper class (home gardens! locavoration! healthy eating!) become the useless curricula of lower class children. The rebuttals seem rather thin gruel: learning math by measuring plots of land? Great, now what to do with the other 180 days of the school year? Making the lessons “come alive,” you say? Please. If doing farm work is to be made educational, inform students after a day of picking beets on hands and knees in the hot sun that such is the fate that awaits them if they don’t pay attention to their lessons, then send them back to the classroom to copy their multiplication tables. If hoeing and weeding not reading and writing were the path to knowledge, why would our ancestors bother to invent school?
And it was the kind of scene that would have Flanagan hearing not a whirring grindstone but chalk down a blackboard.
Sentiments like these are odious to me. As though there weren’t a billion peasant farmers who would sacrifice whatever they could to see their children working chalk on slate and not grain on a stone. Marie Antoinette’s little play farm isn’t all that far away from here.